AWS SAM vs Serverless Framework: Things You Should Know
Serverless framework vs. AWS SAM: which one is better? See this comprehensive comparison to find the difference between both tools and choose the best one for your project.
Choosing the right tool for building an app for your business is the utmost concern for most business owners. There are many tools out there to use when it comes to building a mobile app. Although a software development team will do the main job, you, as a client, need to go into the details.
The majority of all tools used for software development pursue one goal: ease the process of building an app, simplify coding, and speed up the development. In this post, we’ll take a closer look at Serverless Framework vs. AWS SAM. Both are powerful tools used for web application development service providers, but which one is better? Our overriding purpose is to find the difference between the Serverless Framework and AWS SAM and help you choose the right solution to meet the demands of your project. Get comfortable and have a look!
Serverless Framework vs. AWS SAM: A Brief Definition of Both Approaches
Let’s begin with the basics and define what these tools are and where they are used.
Serverless Framework
Serverless Framework allows to develop and deploy AWS Lambda functions, along with the required AWS infrastructure resources. CLI, in this case, provides automation, structure, and best practices out-of-the-box.
Serverless Framework manages the code as well as the infrastructure and supports multiple languages, including Python, Node.js, Java, etc.
Serverless also is a framework meant for simplifying the development process. Serverless technology has been around since 2015 and features two definitive camps:
- Back-End as a service (or simply BaaS), which is used to build an app that features a backend on the cloud. These are mobile apps that come with complex UI.
- Function as a Service or FaaS. In this case, a part of the code is run through event triggers.
Overall, AWS serverless consulting framework makes it easy to code event-driven functions for various providers, including Google Cloud, AWS, Kubeless, and others. Plus, the framework is usually open-source, and it also receives updates regularly.
AWS SAM
The first name of AWS SAM was Project Flourish; the main goal of this tool is to extend the Amazon WebServices Cloudformation. Simply put, it’s another framework, much like Serverless Framework, that allows programmers to write less code when creating serverless apps. However, SAM is more specific to AWS. Besides, its primary configuration file template.yml is built with CloudFormation.
The main AWS SAM components are as follows:
- S3 objects;
- CloudWatch events;
- API actions;
- Amazon SNS notifications;
- Amazon Kinesis objects;
- DynamoDB tables;
- Alexa Events.
Although Serverless Framework and AWS SAM have similar goals and functionalities (both tools guarantee local deployment and work on top of CloudFormation), they have their own merits and demerits. Let’s review AWS SAM and Serverless Framework's advantages and disadvantages.
What Are the Key Advantages and Disadvantages of AWS SAM?
Benefits of AWS SAM
Some software development experts still think that AWS SAM and the Serverless Framework are the same, but there are some differences. The main advantages of AWS SAM are as follows:
Easy to use
You don’t have to spend hours learning how to use it. If you have already worked with CloudFormation, you won’t face any difficulties related to understanding the principles of the SAM syntax.
All Lambda permissions are controlled by AWS
This means that you can use the tool without asking for Lambda permission, which can reduce the CF template size and the technical debt.
Single-deployment configuration
With AWS SAM, one can easily organize related elements and operate on one stack. Plus, this tool can also be used for sharing configuration (timeouts or memory) between various resources. Thus, all related resources can quickly be deployed together as a versioned entity.
Integration with dev tools
Coders use AWS SAM with a set of AWS tools for creating serverless apps. For instance, for debugging or testing the apps built with AWS SAM, programmers can use the AWS CLoud9 IDE. CodeDeploy or CodePipeline are used for building a deployment pipeline.
SAM CLI supports local testing and debugging of Lambda functions, reducing the need for frequent deployments during the development phase.
Extension of AWS CloudFormation
As AWS SAM is an extension of AWS CloudFormation, developers can also use the benefits of AWS CloudFormation deployment capabilities. You can use a set of resources and a myriad of other template options available in AWS CloudFormation.
Auto Scaling
You can provide application auto-scaling rules in the template for your Lambda functions. You can also specify scaling policies according to different metrics: custom CloudWatch metrics, CPU usage, or concurrency. This way, your Lambda functions can be automatically scaled up or down, adapting to application usage.
EventBridge Event Sources
You can use EventBridge as an event source for your Lambda functions. This allows you to connect to and trigger Lambda functions depending on events from multiple Amazon services, custom apps, or third-party SaaS applications. You just need to define EventBridge event rules in your SAM template.
Nested Stacks
You can modularize and hierarchically arrange your serverless application resources by defining nested stacks. It allows for reusing your templates and better resource management.
Setup Centralization
You can centralize the common setup of settings like environment variables and memory size for all Lambda functions in your application usinthe g Globals section in the template. Here, you can provide general characteristics to apply them to numerous resources in your application.
Continuous synchronization of local changes to the cloud
AWS SAM CLI sam sync command automatically synchronizes local changes to the cloud. It helps you speed up your development and cloud-testing workflows.
Drawbacks of SAM
Although the software development market is overloaded with a host of useful tools, you will hardly find a perfect and multi-featured one. SAM vs. Serverless Framework features some drawbacks.
If talking about compassion AWS SAM vs. Serverless Framework difference and trying to find the main disadvantages of this tool, the first aspect that might catch your eye is a limited community of plugin creators compared to Serverless Framework.Although there’s no need for end-users to get stuck with the Swagger, it takes more time to build a final product for developers.
It is also worth noting that this framework is specially sharpened for ABC. Therefore, in some aspects, it imposes its own limitations.
Use cases of AWS Serverless Application Model
So, how can you use AWS SAM in the real world? Here are some of the most common examples.
- Serverless web applications. Obviously, you can build such applications with API Gateway for the frontend APIs and Lambda functions for the backend functionality. You can use a simple and concise method to set up API Gateway authorization, define REST APIs, and utilize Lambda functions to process API requests.
- Event-driven applications. This framework simplifies the creation of event sources, managing permissions, and configuring triggers for Lambda functions. That’s why you can use it for building an event-driven application that reacts to events from different AWS services or external SaaS applications.
- Microservices architectures. You can use SAM to create Lambda functions where microservices can be implemented.
- Chatbots. You can create serverless chatbots and voice applications using SAM, Amazon Connect, AWS Lex, and other conversational AI services.
- Real-time data processing. You can use SAM to create real-time data processing systems of serverless apps. It could be cases when the application processes streaming data from Kinesis or Kafka, uses Lambda functions to execute real-time analytics, and, for instance, stores the outcomes in DynamoDB.
What Are the Key Advantages and Disadvantages of Serverless Framework?
Let’s take a deeper look at all the positive and negative aspects of using a Serverless Framework.
Serverless Framework advantages
Fast and easy to deploy
If your main objective is to build an app fast, using a serverless approach might be the right solution. When choosing this method, an app can be deployed in a few days. The thing is that, in this case, you don’t have to care about the infrastructure. You mainly need to focus on the code, and that’s all.
The Serverless Framework command lines are easier
When choosing this approach, the deploy command is used for both packages, but with SAM, two absolutely different commands are used.
Improved scalability
If your app is successful on the market, it will be easier to make some changes that might accommodate the growth and future development of your application. When choosing a serverless framework, it will be easier to roll with the punches.
More time for building UX
Remember that your first and foremost task is to build an app that caters to the needs of your targeted audience that actually doesn’t care what infrastructure you use. They can only see the user interface and evaluate the app’s performance. When using a serverless framework, you’ll have more spare time to focus on these issues.
Better flexibility
Remember that to start implementing your future app is easier with serverless compared to traditional methods. And this means you can innovate quickly and move on to your next project.
The generated output
For example, the -v flag (or verbose) outputs absolutely any updates to the stack. When you use SAM, updating a stack demonstrates only the following information: “Waiting for update to complete.” Besides, when you delete a stack, the Serverless CLI usually waits until the stack is removed. With SAM, the default Cloud Formation CLI disappears automatically, and you don’t know if the stack is removed or not.
An extensive community of plugins
One of the greatest benefits of a serverless solution is a rich community of plugins that allow programmers to either modify or extend Serverless Framework configuration. It allows you to access numerous plugins, Infrastructure as Code (IaC), and capabilities that are not limited to AWS.
Wide usage
This framework is widely used. It is generally platform- or cloud-neutral, so you can use it not only with AWS but with Google Cloud, Microsoft Azure, and other clouds as well.
Drawbacks of Serverless Framework
Poor quality of some plugins
Not all available plugins are of excellent quality. The choice is broad, but not all can be used when needed most of all. However, all available plugins are open-source, and one can improve their quality.
Lack of operational tools
Unfortunately, programmers are contingent on vendors for monitoring and debugging tools. And the process of debugging distributed systems is usually time-consuming and challenging. Plus, it needs access to various metrics to find the root cause.
Architectural complexity
It is clear that there must be a balance between all the features of your future app. It usually takes a lot of time to define how small the feature must be. Moreover, it is difficult to manage all these functions.
Implementation difficulties
The thing is that testing serverless apps is difficult and time-consuming. The units of integration with serverless FaaS are smaller than other architectures, and that’s why QA experts use integration testing more often. There are also some issues related to deployment and packaging.
Additionally, Serverless Framework doesn’t support shorthand syntax.
Use cases of Serverless Framework
Because this is a general-purpose framework, you can use it for wide range of purposes. The most common cases are web applications, IoT applications, and REST APIs. You can choose it when you have to spend more time on business logic and simplify infrastructure management.
Serverless Framework is also a good option for hybrid cloud and multi-language apps as it allows you to develop applications using different programming languages and cloud service providers. Also, the plugin system and integration capabilities of Serverless Framework may be beneficial for automating DevOps processes.
Comparing AWS SAM with the Serverless Framework
Let’s sum up what has been said in a table:
Conclusion & TechMagic’s Expertise
To wrap up what we’ve covered, we can conclude that both tools are powerful solutions used for building great apps with serverless architecture. We at TechMagic use both solutions regularly to provide serverless application development services. After you look at our comparison table “AWS SAM vs. serverless framework,” you’ll understand which tool better fits the needs of your project.
Acorn-i Case
Let’s have a look at one of our projects — Acorn-i, a powerful online platform that empowers the online presence of brands and improves return from e-commerce investments. The main goal of this platform is to provide users with access to Amazon search analytics. As we already know, AWS SAM offers a Lambda-like execution environment that allows you to locally develop, test, and debug apps defined by SAM templates or through the AWS Cloud Development Kit. And we used AWS Serverless consulting for building Acorn-i. Due to this, we managed to build a more reliable and easy-to-use data platform. Moreover, we successfully enhanced the performance of the existing solution 15 times!
If you are still hesitating and don’t know which tool better suits the needs of your project, contact experts from TechMagic. We’ll help you make the right decision.
FAQ
-
What is the main difference between the Serverless Framework and AWS SAM?
The Serverless Framework is open-sourced. It is designed to deploy serverless applications on multiple cloud platforms. AWS SAM (Serverless Application Model), on the other hand, is specifically tailored for AWS services. It provides a more focused approach for AWS environments.
-
Which framework is more suitable for a multi-cloud serverless architecture?
The Serverless Framework supports various cloud providers such as AWS, Azure, and Google Cloud, so this would be a better option. AWS SAM is limited to AWS services, making it less adaptable for multi-cloud deployments.
-
Can AWS SAM only be used with AWS services?
Yes, AWS SAM is exclusively used with AWS services. It utilizes AWS CloudFormation to manage infrastructure and resources within the AWS ecosystem.
-
Which framework offers better local development and testing capabilities?
Both frameworks provide strong local development and testing features. AWS SAM includes the SAM CLI for local Lambda environment emulation. The Serverless Framework also supports local invocation and debugging, with added flexibility for different environments and cloud providers. So, your choice of framework should depend on specific project requirements and scalability needs.
-
What are the benefits of using the Serverless Framework over AWS SAM for a serverless application?
Benefits of the Serverless Framework over AWS SAM include multi-cloud support (deployment across various cloud providers), a rich plugin ecosystem, and flexibility in integrating with non-AWS services and tools.
linkedin
facebook
twitter
